Section R313-17-4 - Special Procedures for Decisions Associated with Licenses for Uranium Mills and Disposal of Byproduct Material(1) Definitions. For purposes of this rule: (a) "Byproduct material" has the same meaning as defined in 42 U.S.C. Section 2014(e) (2); (b) "License" means a radioactive materials license for a uranium mill or disposal of byproduct material, including any ground water discharge permit incorporated in a license; and (c) "Question and answer hearing" means the informal hearing described in paragraphs (3) through (5) held for the purpose of responding to questions from the public. (2) Scope. This rule R313-17-4 applies only to licensing activities that meet both of the following criteria: (a) they are licensing activities described in R313-17-2(a)(i)(A) through (I); and (b) they are for licenses or license amendments for uranium mills and disposal of byproduct materials. (3) Opportunity for Question and Answer Hearing Prior to Director's Decision. (a) For licensing actions that are subject to the scope of this rule, the division may, at its discretion, schedule a question and answer hearing at the time it proposes the action. (b) If the division does not choose to schedule a question and answer hearing at the time it proposes a licensing action, it shall provide notice to the public of an opportunity to request a question and answer hearing, and it shall schedule and hold a hearing if there is a request from a member of the public. (c) Notice of a hearing or an opportunity to request a hearing under this rule shall be made as provided in R313-17-3(5). Members of the public shall be given at least ten days to request a hearing. (d) The division may combine the question and answer hearing with a licensing hearing held for the purpose of taking public comment on a proposed licensing action. (4) Procedures Prior to Question and Answer Hearing. (a) The division shall provide a notice of the question and answer hearing at least 30 days before the hearing. The notice shall also summarize the applicable procedures, including the obligation to provide questions in advance of the hearing. (b) Any person who proposes to ask questions during the question and answer hearing shall submit the questions to the division. Questions must be received by the division by the deadline specified in the public notice, which shall be no fewer than 15 days after the notice of the question and answer hearing is posted. If a question relies on information that is not included in the licensing record, that information shall be submitted with the questions. The relevance of and the relevant portions of any supporting materials shall be described with reasonable specificity. Information submitted in accordance with this paragraph will become part of the record. (c) If the Director determines that any of the questions submitted will not be answered during the question and answer hearing, as provided in paragraph (5)(f), the Director shall notify the person who submitted the questions prior to the hearing. Notification shall include a statement about the Director's reasons for the determination. (5) Procedures for Question and Answer Hearing. (a) The question and answer hearing shall ordinarily be held in the Department of Environmental Quality offices. Unless the question and answer hearing is held in a place near the proposed facility, the division shall provide an opportunity for the public to participate by telephone or other electronic means. (b) The question and answer hearing will not ordinarily be scheduled for longer than three hours. The division may allocate time to those who have submitted questions after considering the number and nature of the questions submitted. (c) A hearing officer who is not the director or a member of the director's staff shall manage the question and answer hearing. Representatives of the licensee and division staff shall attend the hearing. (d) The question and answer hearing shall be recorded and transcribed. Alternatively, the division may elect to have a court reporter record and transcribe the hearing. (e) The Director shall determine whether the initial and follow-up question will be answered by the applicant, by division staff, or by both. Notwithstanding the Director's decision, the applicant may choose to respond to any question. After the response to a question, the person who submitted the question shall be allowed to follow up with additional questions based on the response provided. (f) Appropriate questions are those that seek specific factual information about the license application, or about other documents created during the licensing process. The following kinds of questions do not require a response during a question and answer hearing: (i) Questions that are not relevant to the licensing action; (ii) Questions that are based on information that is not in the record; (iii) Questions that are vague; (iv) Questions that require speculation; (v) Questions that seek legal conclusions; (vi) Questions that have been previously answered; (vii) Questions that are more appropriately characterized as comments; and (viii) Questions that would not have to be answered during a trial-type hearing. (g) Either the agency or the applicant may elect to answer a question even if it is a question that does not require a response under paragraph (f). No waiver will result from answering a question that does not require a response. (h) Questions requesting information that is clear in the record may be answered by referring the questioner to the record. (i) In the event that a questioner or the applicant disagrees with the Director's determinations under paragraphs (4)(c), (5)(b), or (5)(e), it may request a determination by the hearing officer. If the hearing officer disagrees with the Director's determination, the division or, as appropriate, the applicant may then: (i) comply with the hearing officer's determination during the question and answer hearing; (ii) comply with the hearing officer's determination by responding to the question in writing no fewer than 10 days before the end of the comment period; or (iii) notify the questioner or applicant that it contests the determination, and provide information to the questioner about the procedures available to it under paragraph (5)(j). (j) If a decision of the hearing officer is contested as described in paragraph (5)(i)(iii), the person who asked the question may challenge that failure to comply with the hearing officer's decision on appeal. If the hearing officer's determination is upheld on appeal, the record on appeal shall be supplemented as described in paragraph (6) and R305-7-607. (6) Formal Questioning During Appeal. If no opportunity for a question and answer hearing is provided, or if an opportunity that was provided is found by the ALJ to have been deficient, an opportunity for questions and answers shall be provided on appeal as described in R305-7-607. This opportunity for questions and answers on appeal shall be available only to a petitioner who has exhausted procedures and remedies available under paragraphs R313-17-4(1) through R313-17-4(5). The scope of questions and answers on appeal shall be limited by the scope of the deficiency.
Utah Admin. Code R313-17-4
Adopted by Utah State Bulletin Number 2015-5, effective 2/17/2015