Section R305-7-214 - Review and Determinations(1) The procedures and standards for resolving a permit review challenge are specified in Section 19-1-301.5; see in particular paragraphs ( 9) through (1 5). (2) The standard of review for the Director's factual, technical, and scientific determinations specified in Section 19-1-301.5(14)(b) and (15)(c)(ii) is explained as follows: (a) The petitioner has the burden of proof; (b) Marshaling the evidence is a natural extension of the petitioner's burden of proof; (c) For each factual, technical, and scientific determination challenged by petitioner, the petitioner is required to marshal and acknowledge the evidence in the record that supports the Director's determination. Such determination shall be overturned as clearly erroneous only if the petitioner has proven, after marshaling, that the Director's determination is not supported. See Subsections 19-1-301.5(6)(d)(v)(G) and (H) and 19-1-301.5(14); and (d) If the petitioner fails to marshal, there is a presumption that the Director's factual, technical, and scientific determination is not clearly erroneous. (3) The standard of review for non-factual determinations provided in Section 19-1-301.5(15)(c)(i) recognizes that the Director has been granted substantial discretion to interpret the division's governing statutes and rules. Utah Admin. Code R305-7-214
Amended by Utah State Bulletin Number 2015-24, effective 11/20/2015