Haw. Code R. § 18-235-1.14

Current through September, 2024
Section 18-235-1.14 - "Substantial gainful business or occupation", defined
(a) As used in this chapter, "substantial gainful business or occupation" means a business or occupation that is both substantial and gainful. It is substantial if it involves significant physical or mental activity even if the individual works on a part-time basis, does less work, is paid less, or has fewer responsibilities than when the individual worked prior to the disability. The business or occupation is gainful if it is done for monetary consideration or profit.
(b) It shall be presumed that an individual whose earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation.

Example 1: Taxpayer retires from employment on disability that is total and permanent. After retirement, Taxpayer accepts another job and Taxpayer's earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because Taxpayer's earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year.

Example 2: Taxpayer retires as a teacher on disability that is total and permanent. Taxpayer begins babysitting children and selling items. Taxpayer's earned income from these two businesses is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because Taxpayer's earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year.

(c) In the case of husband and wife filing a return jointly and only one of the spouses is disabled, only the disabled spouse's earned income is measured.

Example 1: A and B file a joint income tax return. Only A is disabled. A's earned income is less than $25,000 for the taxable year. B's earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year. For purposes of determining whether an individual is engaged in a "substantial gainful business or occupation," only the disabled spouse's earned income is measured when a joint tax return is filed. A is not engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because A's earned income is less than $30,000 for the taxable year.

(d) For purposes of this section, earned income includes wages, salaries, tips, business interest income, other employment compensation, and gross earnings from self-employment for the taxable year unless gross earnings for the taxable year are less than $60,000, in which case all net earnings from self-employment are included in earned income in lieu of gross earnings from self-employment. For purposes of this subsection, all entities shall be disregarded. Earned income does not include interest, dividends, capital gains, pensions, or deferred compensation.

Example 1: Taxpayer retires on disability that is total and permanent and receives an insurance settlement. Taxpayer does not engage in any other employment. The insurance settlement is invested and Taxpayer receives $35,000 in interest, dividends, and capital gains during the taxable year. Taxpayer is not engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because earned income does not include interest, dividends, and capital gains.

Example 2. Taxpayer works for wages and receives $20,000 in wages for the taxable year. Taxpayer also has net earnings from self-employment of $8,000 and gross earnings from self-employment of $75,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer has earned income of $95,000 for the taxable year and is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because earned income includes the $20,000 in wages and $75,000 of gross earnings from self-employment.

Example 3. Taxpayer has gross earnings from selfemployment of $60,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because earned income includes the $60,000 of gross earnings from self-employment.

Example 4. Taxpayer has gross earnings from self-employment of $59,999 and net earnings from self-employment of $30,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer has earned income of $30,000 for the taxable year and is not engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation. Taxpayer's earned income includes net earnings from self-employment because gross earnings from self-employment are less than $60,000 for the taxable year.

Example 5. Taxpayer works for wages and receives $10,000 in wages for the taxable year. Taxpayer also has gross earnings from self-employment of $59,999 and net earnings from self-employment of $25,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer has earned income of $35,000 for the taxable year and is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because earned income includes the $10,000 of wages and the $25,000 of net earnings from self-employment.

Example 6. Taxpayer has structured her business as a C corporation for which she is sole shareholder. The corporation has gross earnings of $75,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer earns no wages, but the corporation pays taxpayer a dividend of $25,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer has earned income of $75,000 for the taxable year and is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because earned income includes the $75,000 of gross income earned by her corporation. Entities such as corporations are disregarded for purposes of determining Taxpayer's earned income.

(e) The presumption with respect to the $30,000 earned income limitation set forth in subsection (b) is applicable to all totally and permanently disabled persons, including the following:
(1) A person who lost or is born without both feet at or before the ankle;
(2) A person who lost or is born without both hands at or above the wrist;
(3) A person who lost or is born without one hand and one foot;
(4) A person who has an injury or defect resulting in permanent and complete paralysis of both legs or both arms or one leg and one arm; or
(5) A person who has an injury or defect resulting in incurable imbecility or mental illness.

Example 1: Taxpayer retires on disability that is total and permanent because Taxpayer loses both feet at the ankles in an accident. After retirement, Taxpayer accepts another job and Taxpayer's earned income from that job is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year. Taxpayer is engaged in a substantial gainful business or occupation because Taxpayer's earned income is greater than $30,000 for the taxable year.

Haw. Code R. § 18-235-1.14

[Eff 2/16/82; am 9/3/94; am and ren § 18-235-1.14 8/28/98] (Auth: HRS §§ 231-3(9), 235-118) (Imp: HRS §§ 235-1, 237-17, 237-24(13))
Am 4/20/2019