Supreme Court of New York March 2019 casesStar Auto Sales of Queens LLC v. FilardoSaunders Ventures, Inc. v. Catcove Grp., Inc.Binn v. Muchnick, Golieb & Golieb, P.C.Nelson v. N.Y. City Transit Auth.Gibbs v. Rochdale Vill., Inc.Flaherty v. Midtown Moving & Storage Inc.Choe v. HesmanWu v. Cont'l Truck Body Corp.PRG Assocs. L.P. v. Planet Organic Holding Corp.Kestenbaum v. GlobusSpadaro v. Best Mkt. of W. Babylon 2Azrak v. Carter Enters. LLCLaw Offices of Brad A. Kauffman, PLLC v. Dell & Dean, PLLCCardi v. DerielBenny Blanco, Inc. v. Invest Hosp., LLCMatamoro v. Horatio Mgmt. Park v. FlynnU.S. Bank v. HershkoOrtiz v. HackneyMeans v. Beach Improvement, LLCPeople v. GoodsonLai Fong Chan v. Lee ChanClay v. MendietaAIG Prop. Cas. Co. v. Long Island Power Auth. (LIPA)Fischer v. Am. Biltrite, Inc. (In re N.Y. City Asbestos Litig.)Comm'rs of the State Ins. Fund v. Drive N.J. Ins.Mireyavasquez v. Glob. Constr. Mgmt., LLCBahouali v. Fordham Univ.Jones v. RosenblumQ Semiconductor Inc. v. Globalfoundries U.S. 2 LLCFrancisco v. Kiara Foods, Inc.Armental v. 401 Park Ave. S. Assocs., LLCGrimaldi v. SangiOriginal Homestead Rest., Inc. v. SeibelPub. Adm'r of Kings Cnty. v. N.Y. Presbyterian Hosp. -N.Y. Weill Cornell Ctr.Long Island Med. & Gastroenterology Assocs., P.C. v. Mocha Realty Assocs., LLCSchwindt v. Niagara Mohawk Power Corp.Cortland Apts., LLC v. Simbari Design Architecture, PLLCUpdyke v. Long Island Developmental Disabilities Servs. OfficeBabcock v. A.O. Smith Corp. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Am. Empire Surplus Lines Ins. Co. v. Arch Specialty Ins.Stathis Enters., LLC v. City of N.Y.Isayev v. Wiaragh-BleusGenger v. GengerVoloshko v. Planet Motor Cars Inc.Lowe v. ReyesStop Irresponsible Frick Dev. v. Landmarks Pres. Comm'nSzarfharc v. BeatonGlykas v. Roosevelt Island Operating Corp.Akter v. N.Y.C. Health & Hosps. Corp.Brown v. DossantosGraham v. 702 Rockaway Ave.Am. Transit Ins. Co. v. FosterSinatra v. City of N.Y.Coles v. BranchUpper W. Side Neighbors Ass'n v. City of N.Y.Alexander v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.U.S. Bank v. AboelenenJackson v. N.Y.C. Emps.' Ret. Sys.Gerardi v. Hudson Yards, the Related Cos.Montoya v. Surma Cab Corp.New Penn Fin., LLC v. 360 Mortg. Grp., LLCU.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. AllenBank of N.Y. Mellon v. LaskinPirrelli v. DickGuzovskiy v. WeingartenCabrera v. Liberty Elevator Co.Albin v. A.O. Smith Water Prods., Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Baines v. Daily News, L.P.Jaber v. ElayyanGiordano v. A.W. & S. Constr. Co.Kluge v. SubotnickLin v. StandfordRao v. SchneiderPiedmont 60 Broad St., LLC v. First Capital Real Estate Advisors, LPHernandez v. Brouse3839 Holding LLC v. FarnsworthMiller v. MillerFV-I, Inc. v. ThomasBrowder v. Amsterdam Nursing Home Corp. (1992)Wolf v. Walgreens Boots All., Inc.Mandato v. Animal Care & Control of N.Y.C., Inc.City of N.Y. v. BaldeoMcKissack Grp., Inc. v. MacFarlandSweeney v. River Manor, Corp.Liu v. Jun Chen & Etherdeg Ltd.Polakoff v. N.Y. City Dep't. of Bldgs.BSD 26 Maeem LLC v. SacksW. Harlem Cmty. Org. v. West-Harlem Cmty. Org. Local Dev. Corp.Springfield Norse Realty, LLC v. Spiegel & Utrera, P.C.Rodriguez v. RodriguezFuruya v. AMC Entm't Inc.Gonzalez v. DemairoIn re La Hermosa ChurchGuzman v. First Chinese Presbyterian Cmty. Affairs Home Attendant Corp.Harris v. ReaganLancman v. De BlasioOmansky v. 160 Chambers St. Owners Inc.Macarthur Props. I, LLC v. GalbraithHill v. Full 360 Inc.Levitz v. Morgan Fuel & Heating Co.Colella v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Lamb 79 & 2 Corp. v. HeibergerMcNeil v. Hunter Roberts Constr. Grp., L.L.C.Stevens v. Via Transp., Inc.Scott v. Kosova Props. Inc.Kennedy v. 30W26 Land, L.P.Maple-Gate Anesthhsiologists, P.C. v. NasrinMartinez v. Da Hua House, Inc.Law Enforcement Emps. Benevolent Ass'n v. City of N.Y. Office of Collective Bargaining-Bd. of CertificationLuciano v. One City Block LLCHamadi v. MilordCitibank v. McNishM.H.B. v. Ethical Culture Fieldston Sch.Robinson v. Exec. Assocs. N. ISingh v. JFB Realty LLCBaity v. BurkeJanczewski v. 388 Realty Owner LLCBattle v. Budget Truck RentalPrzybylo v. BullChang v. Bronstein Props. LLCPeople v. CorinesHFZ Bryant Park Owner LLC v. S. BP Assocs., LLCPrystupa v. Crowne Plaza Resort & Golf ClubEsposito v. ReedGutierrez v. City of YonkerPeople v. JohnsonBesler v. UzieriProscia v. 50 E. 78 L.P.Heaney v. 337 Mansion Ave.Stone & Broad Inc. v. Nextel of N.Y., Inc.Riviera Produce Corp. v. ParkEmigrant Bank Fine Art Fin., LLC v. Kasmin Gallery Inc.U.S. Immigration Fund LLC v. LitowitzSukenik v. City of N.Y.Rice v. CuevasSecured Capital Partners, LLC v. Wansdown Props. Corp. N.V.Lackey v. 62 E. 87th St. Owners Corp.UMF Contracting Corp. v. Arch Specialty Ins. Co.Roy v. Chen HongJohn v. Jemcom Canal Del, LLC.Winston v. ShimMoran v. Delacruz-EspinalMontouri v. CorwinAtkins v. Ovation Risk Planners, Inc.Abid v. Corp. Express Inc.N.Y. Bone & Joint Specialists, PLLC v. Goldstein, Rubinton & Difazio, PCJacobson v. Jemrock Realty Co.Cambridge Packing Co. v. LajaunieMcMahon v. NegronYong Jun Li v. A.Z.N. Realty LLCMatthews v. ChaudhriYoung v. Avon Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Barry v. LeeSheehan v. 30 Park Place Residential LLCWard v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth. Transit Adjudication BureauBoswick v. Bronte SPV LLCMoore v. URS Corp.Torres v. PorcelliU.S. Bank v. AllenFeggins v. BenjaminWatkins v. N.Y. State Div. of Human RightsSilkowski v. Stanley E. Matthews, D.D.S., & Dental Specialty Assocs., P.C.Animah v. Tabi Agyei & DTG Enters., Inc.Kostro v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous. & Cmty. RenewalParker v. Arris Contracting Co.Mountain & Isles, LLC v. Gillz, LLCRed Hook 160 LLC v. Borough Constr. Grp. LLCDiaz v. RodriguezAppleton v. City of N.Y.Garcia v. 1000 Dean LLCSkerrett v. LIC Site B2 Owner, LLCHall-Ellis v. N.Y. Presbyterian Hosp.Hayner Hoyt Corp. v. Nayana, Inc.Subway Real Estate Corp. v. SaleemWilkow v. AraqueKoyl v. GaudiusoNaula v. Utokilen LLCAm. Express Bank v. BardachU.S. Bank v. SinghAriale v. City of N.Y.Bd. of Managers of Be@william Condo. v. 90 William St. Dev. Grp. LLCBorrometi v. AddeoG.S. v. B.S.Bellerose Dental, P.C. v. Liberty Universal Corp.Pizarro v. Dennis James Boyle, Inc.Hepps v. N.Y. State Dep't of HealthGarcia v. 184th W. 10th St. Corp.Diaz v. Combe Inc.Garcia v. Takeko TakeshigePeople v. EdwardsScotti v. Tough Mudder Inc.Total Asset Recovery Servs., LLC v. MetLife, Inc.Tolmach v. Burton Langer DMD & Laureen Langer DDS, P.C.Stephanie R. v. John R.Higgins v. Zenker Corp.Weber v. PetrieUniv. Ave., LLC v. Simbari Design Architecture, PLLCMcGown v. Hudson Meridian Constr. Grp., LLC2952 Victory Blvd. Pump Corp. v. BhattyDemetrio v. Clune Constr. Co.One Bryant Park v. Permasteelisa Cladding Techs., Ltd.Breslin v. Richmond Univ. Med. Ctr.Pedrini v. JLJ IV Enters., Inc.Shah v. 20 E. 64TH St.Goundan v. Pav-Lak Contracting Inc.Rios v. SpelmanHRM Capstone P'ship, Inc. v. Cantor Fitzgerald, L.P.Lam v. 933 60th St. Realty Inc.Lower Manhattan Inner City Real Estate Assocs. LLC v. 56 Leonard LLCKogan v. N.Y.C. Emps. Ret. Sys.Dugan v. Port Auth. of N.Y. & N.J.245-02 Owner LLC v. CVS Albany, L.L.C.Guardian Life Ins. Co. of Am. v. BrownRadison v. WeWork Cos.Am. Access Cas. Ins. Co. v. B & H PharmacyFields v. Dep't of Educ. of N.Y.Horne v. D & A Sand & Gravel Inc.People v. O'MearaKolakowski v. 10839 Assocs. ESX Servs. LLC v. Bd. of Managers of the Essex House Condo.People v. WilliamsBernard v. The Stop & Shop Supermarket Co.Karlsson v. Westchester Cnty. HealthCare Corp.Mortimer Offshore Servs. Ltd. v. Manufacturas Orga LtdaWisseman v. WissemanPeople v. AcostaChaney v. James River Ins. Co.Park v. Home Depot U.S.A., Inc.Daum Global Holdings Corp. v. Ybrant Digital Ltd.Suarez v. MahmudGreene v. GreeneFCI Enters. Inc. v. Richmond Capital Grp., LLCSarfati v. Covenant Mgmt. Grp., LLCIn re City of New YorkLancer & Loader Grp., LLC v. Am. Tack & Hardware Co.Fed. Home Loan Bank of Bos. v. Moody's Corp.Schalman v. Aquatic Recreational Mgmt., Inc.14TH St. Owner LLC v. Westside Donut 6TH Ave. Ventures LLCHSBC Bank U.S. v. IslamWhite v. CuomoRapson Invs. LLC v. 45 E. 22nd St. Prop. LLCDecanio v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Baxter v. CamposAaronson v. MaglioneCnty. of Suffolk v. DistefanoJaffa v. City of N.Y.CM & Assocs. Constr. Mgmt. LLC v. Barrier Grp. Inc.NKN Constr., Inc. v. DPC N.Y., Inc.Heth v. Satterlee Stephens Burke & Burke LLPU.S. Bank v. AllenSemsysco GMBH v. Globalfoundries Inc.Mayers v. Calamaras Realty Corp.Ascolese v. Interstate Waste Servs.Schutt v. Dynasty Transp. of Ohio, Inc.Focacci v. One E. River Place Realty Co.Rosa v. 267 E. 202 LLCGibbs v. Kings Harbor Health Servs.Watson v. ABS Contracting NY Corp.Vaughn v. Triumphant Church of Jesus ChristUmbreit v. FuentesAll Saints Coop. Realty Corp. v. All Saints Co Realty Corp.Golio v. GreensteinChvetsova v. Family Smile DentalTMT Entm't Grp., Inc. v. Michael Gasparro, Gasparro Mgmt. LLCFrancis v. TSA Stores, Inc.U.S. Bank Nat'l Ass'n v. ForrestDNP Builders, LLC v. Ny Estimating Servs., Inc.USA Battery, LLC v. UPS Power Mgmt., Inc.Williams v. Westland S. Shore Mall LPNugent v. City of N.Y.Zurzolo v. Brickman Facility Sols., LLCEhl Funding LLC v. Fyre Festival LLCCitigroup Glob. Mkts., Inc. v. Fin. Indus. Regulatory Auth. (Finra), Inc.Friedel v. Asbestos Corp. (In re Eighth Judicial Dist. Asbestos Litig.)Denson v. Donald J. Trump for President, Inc.Robinson v. StanfordGarnica v. Hong BSD LLCAbrams v. Bd. of Managers of 25 Beekman Place Condo.Inwald Enters. v. HumphreyPoventud v. Devereux Found.Molina v. Garrison Protective Servs., Inc.Slaughter v. City of New YorkPadilla v. BodeyKong v. Morrison-Tennenbaum PLLCStone & Broad Inc. v. Nextel of N.Y., Inc.Nuur v. 223 Ave. B, LLC.Carroll v. N.Y.C. Health & Hosps. Corp.Dovbeniuk v. 2222 Mgmt. Corp.Hillabrant v. FalangaAlston v. Golfo21ST Century Ins. v. BaptisyeIn re Application of MatzellPichardo v. N.Y.C. Tr. Auth.Petrisko v. Animal Med. Ctr.Re v. Amchem Prods., Inc.Licul v. A. O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)E. River Fifties Alliance, Inc. v. City of N.Y.Levine v. PincusVBGO Penn Plaza, LLC v. Salon Media Grp., Inc.Jewish Press, Inc. v. N.Y. Dep't of Educ.Picozzi v. PowellM.L.M. v. R.G.M.Town of Southold v. Basso Motors Mfg. & Equip. Repair, LLC.Mcan LLC v. Thomas Costa, Accredited Bus. Solutions, LLCWoolcock v. Mt. Sinai St. Lukes-Roosevelt & Continuum Health PartnersPIRS Capital, LLC v. Salisbury Sales, Inc.America v. GMM Baking Corp.Lewis v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re Asbestos)SM Sydell Hotels LLC v. Yucaipa U.S. Hosp. Partners Holdings, Inc.The Original Crunch Roll Factory LLC v. SantoraPatrick Quadrozzi & PCM Dev. LLC v. Claude Castro & Claude Castro & Assocs. PLLCMenard v. N.Y. State Bd. of ParoleAm Pitt Hotel, LLC v. 400 5TH Ave., L.P.Espinal v. N.Y.C. Econ. Dev. Corp.Gillen v. Town of Hempstead Town Bd.JP Morgan Chase Funding Inc. v. HehmanPalma v. Verizon N.Y. Inc.Njie v. OliverasProgressive Direct Ins. Co. v. Powerline Cycles, Inc.In re Tax Foreclosure Action Borough of Brooklyn Hutchings v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Terence Cardinal Cooke Health Ctr. v. Comm'r of Health of StateCole v. LoducaEngelbert v. Flushing Commons Prop. Owner, LLCNL Brand Holdings LLC v. LeporeWalker v. BabalolaLam v. ArchitectSina v. United Frontier Mut. Ins. Co.Henry Quentzel Plumbing Supply Co. v. Riggs Plumbing & Heating at 58th, Inc.Lee v. OrioloU.S. Bank v. FitzpatrickMaddalon v. Del ColRoman v. Nikodemo Operating Corp.Gould v. Fort 250 Assocs., LLCNationstar Mortg. LLC v. CorraoRodriguez v. KrummelBoyce v. WeberLoeb v. YoonLee v. Nygaard Investigation,, Inc.Morgan v. Am. Home Assurance Co. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Park Side Constr. Builders Corp. v. Paco Lafayette, LLCRojas v. GartnerBisogno v. LibertellaKaffl v. Glen Cove Hosp.A.P.T. Techs., LLC v. Westfalia Techs., Inc.Ripley v. Marriott Hotel Servs., Inc.140 W. 57th St. Bldg. LLC. v. BerrieSaavedra v. IsabellAm. Transit v. Flour City Bagels, LLCBumbolo v. Faxton St. Luke's HealthcareHilton Resorts Corp. v. VillelaNY Prime Holding LLC v. Nationstar Mortg., LLCButler v. N.Y. City Transit Auth.Fondechene v. DMC Servs. LLCBrown v. City of N.Y.Bilicki v. Syracuse Univ.Sion v. Grant Mgmt. Servs., Co.Miles v. CardoU.S. Bank v. DalyBethpage Fed. Credit Union v. SepyashvilyManhattan Leasing Enters., Ltd. v. EspositoBeatrice Invs., LLC v. 940 Realty LLCLinsky v. Algoma Door, Inc. (In re N.Y. City Asbestos Litig.)Young v. Avon Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)Sargeant v. Walt Witman Mall LLC.HSBC Bank U.S. v. Wireless Express, Inc.Stone v. 685 Fifth Ave. Owner, LLCM.G. v. Bronx Glob. Learning Inst.Merch. Cash & Capital, LLC v. Novo Interiors, LLCMiller v. Giaquinto Bros., LLCA.M. v. Holy Resurrection Greek Orthodox Church of BrookvilleCharles v. WolfsonEROS Int'l PLC v. Mangrove PartnersKS Trade LLC v. Int'l Gemological Inst., Inc.Davis v. Columbia Univ. Med. Ctr.Lupo v. Anna's Lullaby Café LLCM.E. Zukerman & Co. v. RashidMaggio v. Consol. Edison Co. of N.Y., Inc.Black Pearl Glob. Opportunity Fund v. Summit Equtites LLCRycko v. StellatosMaridakis v. Amchem Prods., Inc. (In re N.Y.C. Asbestos Litig.)E.C. v. Safe Coach Inc.Tahari v. Bliss-Direct Inc.Moore v. CabaretFed. Nat'l Mortg. Assoc. v. BravoAm. Express Bank v. SchaeferWMC Mortg. Corp. v. VandermulenApplication Under Article 7 of the Real Prop. Tax Law By NFR Gateway, LLC v. City of Niagara FallsSonaal Indus., Inc. v. N.Y. city Loft Bd.Khan v. RoszkowskiTarar v. Island House Tenants Corp.Langer v. LangerBarry v. Berkley Realty Assocs.Rosenberg Feldman Smith, LLP v. Ninety Five Madison Co.Dean/Wolf Architects v. GottliebMarages v. 121 Realty (2013) LLCEndicott Meats, Inc. v. A La Turk, Inc.Judlau Contracting Inc. v. Metro. Transp. Auth. Capital Constr.Fairley v. N.Y. Div. of Hous. & Cmty. Renewal (In re Fairley)Newton v. Nan Shan Local Dev. Corp.DiMattia v. City of New YorkAboutaam v. Dow Jones & Co.Arias v. City of N.Y.McRae v. EPS Iron Works, Inc.Whittingham v. ThomasSchirmer v. PiazzaEmpire Ctr. for Pub. Policy v. Office of Payroll Admin. N.Y.Martinez v. Jerome Med., PLLCWoodcock v. BirnbaumAuerbach v. Suffolk Cnty. Comm. of the Conservative Party Comm. for Environmentally Sound Dev. v. Amsterdam Ave. Redevelopment Assocs. LLCCetin v. ChoeB.J. v. Kingsbridge Court Hous. Dev. Fund Corp.Dilorenzo v. ToledanoDe Jesus v. Cnty. of NassauChang v. 127 E. 92 LLCPhramus, Inc. v. Metro. Opera Ass'n, Inc.Carter Ledyard & Milburn LLP v. BicalPui Kum Ng Lee v. Chatham Green, Inc.Hobbs v. MTA Capital Constr.Audette v. Toussaint-MilfordDike v. BouhoucheAn-Jung v. Rower LLCRotondi v. RotondiN.Y.C. Civilian Complaint Review Bd. v. Office of the Dist. Attorney416 Mgmt. LLC v. Tax Comm'n of N.Y.People v. LetangA.C. v. Brentwood Union Free Sch. Dist. Castellanos v. ArbabzadehBarden v. City of N.Y.Dilmanian v. ZarOliva v. The Long Island R.R. Co.VFS Leon, LLC v. PritchettOyewole v. RichmondBastidas v. Go Airborne, LLCHodge v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Hodge v. N.Y.C. Transit Auth.Fora Fin. Advance, LLC. v. L & L Constr. Dev., Inc.Lind v. Tishman Constr. Corp. of N.Y.Ouattara v. Andrades Transp. Inc.EV 1st Ave. LLC v. 219 Ave. A NYC LLCOakdale III LLC v. Deutsche Bank Nat'l Tr. Co.McKesson v. PirroBd. of Managers of Residential Section of Plaza Condo. v. FranzeseDimasi v. McKuhanGomez v. Markham438 W. 20 St., LLC v. BaresCombes v. Suit-Kote Corp.Paulicopter - CIA. Paulista De Helicoperto Ltda. - Taxi Aereo v. Bank of Am.Bank of N.Y. Mellon v. JohnsonHSBC Bank U.S. v. AhmadSoto v. LinaresBisagni v. Squires-SussmanShulman v. Brenntag N. Am., Inc.Arkadia Props. v. De OcaIDS Prop. Cas. Ins. Co. v. DurantBorremans v. GardnerHill v. OgokeFriedman v. Blakeman Babcock v. A.O. Smith Corp. (In re Asbestos)Doskotch v. PisockiStabilis Fund II LLC v. CBRE, Inc.Vargas v. S.F. Assocs. Ltd. P'shipN.Y.C. Transit Auth. v. Accelerated Surgical Ctr. of N. JerseyMani v. Elite Mgmt., Inc.John v. BrannRusnak v. Utica Mut. Ins. Co.Quito v. PCS Mgmt., LLCBd. of Managers of Be@william Condo. v. 90 William St. Dev. Grp. LLCA.E. Rosen Elec. Co. v. Plank, LLCSclafani v. Jopal Realty, LLCDayan v. DayanParson v. Elstrom (In re estate of Parson)Laughtman v. Long Island Jewish Valley StreamJeongyi Kang v. Seville Cent.Roman v. BatesB&M Kingstone, LLC v. Mega Int'l Commercial Bank Ltd.Flores v. AcostaSegev v. 262 N 9 LLCTufamerica, Inc. v. Allegro Media Grp., Allegro Media Corp.Lev v. RosenbergFlorio v. A.O. Smith Water Prods. Co. (In re N.Y. C. Asbestos Litig.)Xiu Rong Yang v. ShiuLiburd v. AlliCalleja v. AI 229 W. 43rd St. Prop. Owner, LLCMetro. N.Y. Synod of the Evangelical Lutheran Church in Am. v. Emanuel