Supreme Court of New York November 2010 casesMESSINA v. DEBLASIPreserve Scenic Perinton Alliance, Inc. v. PorterN. Shore Mgt. v. N.Y. State D.O.L.Stewart Title Ins. Co. v. TimoneyNaughton v. City of New York151 Mulberry St. Corp. v. Italian Am. MuseumMatter of Roberts v. New York City HealthALI v. DeSANTISCounter-Tech Indus., Inc. v. Granmarb, Inc.City of New York v. Good Friends Realty Corp.Armstrong v. Sensormatic/ADTMac Land Co. v. East End CementForrest v. TierneyNew York City Campaign Finance Board v. MahadeoZHONG v. FATE REALTYTriangle R Inc. v. Praetorian Ins. Co.Deutsche Bank Sec. v. Lexington DrakeR.D. Best Land Constr. v. GallipoliYoung v. NYC Health & Hosp. Corp.People v. SanchezTorpe v. ThornCOX v. NAP CONSTR. CO., INC.Rome v. North Shore Cent. School Dist.In re Hampshire Country v. Assr. Vil. MamaroneckTRICARICO v. TOW OF OYSTER BAYOrszulak v. A.O. Smith Water Prods.Kaplansky v. SteinbokJENNINGS v. TEACHERS COLLEGEEmpire State Ch. of Assoc. Bldrs. v. SmithIn Matter of Schroko v. County of NassauWay v. Nihar Corp.EMERY CELLI BRINCKERHOFF ABADY LLP v. ROSEARUTA v. LO BUEBaxter v. Sandy Hollow Assoc.Property Clerk v. FordWilliams v. SinghHumane League of Philadelphia v. Berman Co.Pres. Scenic Perinton Alliance v. PorterIn Matter of Chevron U.S.A.Pritzker v. Park South Lofts LLCBridgehampton Dev. Corp. v. County of SuffolkAruta v. ValenzianoKITTELSTAD v. LOSCO GROUPMurray v. Empire City Subway CompanyCons. Direc. Choices v. N.Y. State Off. of MedicaidWright v. Champion Prop. Mgt.Brandes v. City of New YorkHengstler v. RiveraGallipoli v. RussoIn re Schlossberg v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous.Frebar Dev. Corp. v. PosnerIn re New York City Asbestos LitigationHSBC Bank USA v. SchwartzVitello v. KatzKLIMAR v. JAINFORT GREENE COUNCIL, INC. v. CITY OF NEW YORKMATTER OF CITY OF NEW YORKMatter of Hartford v. MulcahyHenry v. P. Deblasio Inc.Gersten v. LemkeFort Greene v. City of N.YMessina v. DeblasiEMERY CELLI BRINCKERHOFF ABADY LLP v. ROSEJENNINGS v. COLLArcher Capital Fund, L.P. v. Eagle Rlty., LLCIn re Uniformed Firefighters Ass'nJOINT VENTURE v. SOL GREENBERG SONS INTL.Richards v. Office of the N.Y. State ComptrollerRose Assocs. v. 8-26 Realty Corp.JONES v KURNIDESCMIA PARTNERS EQUITY LIMITED v. O'NEILLGOFF v. ROOSEVELT UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICTChang v. 168 Realty Corp.ROSA v. DIAZCohen v. Village of IrvingtonGecmc 2007-C1 Ditmars Lodging, LLC v. Mohola, LLCROBERTS v. HEALTH HOSPS. CORP.DEV. DON'T DESTROY (BROOKLYN) v. EMPIRE STATENaughton v. City of New YorkPENNBUS REALTIES v. H EIGHTH AVENUE ASSOCIATESStalker v. Stewart Tenants Corp.Studebaker-Worthington Lease v. Authentic MexicanAmerican Express Centurion Bank v. BajekIQUIQUE v. TAXI EL UNIVERSAL INC.IN RE SMITH v. N. Y. CITY D.O.E.N.Y. Hos. Med. Ctr. of Queens v. Country Wide Ins.Mercado v. Am. Sec. Ins.Devlin v. Blaggards III Rest. Corp.Soldiers' v. Carlton RegencyFernandes v. FernandesRyan v. Breezy Point Coop., Inc.Albano v. Town of IslipBrown v. KerselliusKhader v. New York City Hous. Auth.Jetblue Airways Corp. v. StephensonColonna v. Banco Popular North AmericaMetcalf v. Progressive InsBac Home Loans v. WesterveltCHI SHUN CHANG v. 168 REALTY CORP.Icarus Assocs. v. N.Y.C. Sch. Constr. Auth.In re Edison Parking, LLC v. New YorkCent. Suffolk Hosp. Found v. N. Fork Radio.DeMoya v. SinhaIn re Michael F.X. RyanShami v. F.O.A.NFrench v. SchiavoSaurenman v. Village of SouthhamptonVessella v. Astro Masonry Supply Co., LLCIN THE MAT. OF SMITH v. N.Y.C. DEP. OF EDUC.Kelly v. Bastianic8 Catherine St. v. NJC ConstrCohen v. Village of IrvingtonCHI SHUN CHANG v. 168 REALTYPhysicians Comm. v. HoganBac Home Loans Servicing v. WesterveltWilderhomes, LLC v. ZautnerIn the Mtr. of School Educ. v. Brd. of TrusteesLIU SHUN NG v. N.Y.C. TRANSIT AUTH.Gongora v. New York City Dep't of Educ.ELMOWITZ v. DUNNE FOLEYIn Matter of Social Serv. v. City of New YorkA D Intl. Corp. Defi. Ben. Pension v. TerziForward v. FoschiLiddle v. LiddleIDEAL STEEL SUPPLY CORP. v. BEILMcNamara v. MarinoAlers v. Verizon N.Y., Inc.IN MATTER OF ABRAHAM v. HANHUI LUMorales v. City of N.Y.Goldstein v. Drew Univ.Brooklyn Fed. Sav. Bank v. 9096 Meserole St.HSBC Mortgage Corp. (USA) v. CohenIn Matter of Thomas v. RheaCarltun on the Park, Ltd. v. WeitzmanKITTELSTAD v. LOSCO GROUP, INC.People v. CristinPeople v. LammySTEIN v. ART STUDENTS LEAGUE OF NEW YORKGreenberg Farrow v. Renaissance EquityPeople v. DegoutPeople v. HernandezBERDE v. NORTH SHOREIn re Gur-Arie v. New York State D.O.H.Griffon V. LLC v. 11 E. 36th LLCMatter of Goewey v. SteinerR.D. Best Land Const. Corp. v. Tr. Under GallipoliBuchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, P.C. v. StiegBurgers Bar Five Towns v. Burger Holdings Corp.Coaxum v. Metcon Constr., Inc.Washington Mut. Bank v. PhillipBelok v. Department of Housing PreservationOrosz v. EppigShenendehowa Cent. Sch. Dist. v. Civil ServGuzman v. ArmstrongPeople v. Sanchez68 Burns New Holding v. Burns St. Owners Corp.Fernandes v. FernandesBurtman v. BrownMatter of Ward v. KellySavillo v. Greenpoint Landing Assoc, L.L.C.Persichilli v. MetropolitanSAM TELL SON, INC. v. GPH PARTNERS LLCLiddle v. LiddleBAEZ v. STATEMam Properties, LLC v. Omnipoint Communications, Inc.Cruzado v. FischerMatter of Firestone v. ScomelloFine Art Fin., LLC v. TawilZOLLER v. NAGYRICHARDS v. THE GREAT ATLANTICMorton v. McKennaNORTHE GROUP, INC. v. SPREAD NYC, LLCOi Tai Chan v. Society of Shaolin Temple, Inc.People v. HernandezNyctl 1998-1 Trust v. CruzEUM v. STEPHENSLeslie v. BekkerBalducci v. VelasquezMiranda v. City of N.YBrandes v. City of N.YMcDonald v. KohanfarsD'Anna v. Inc. Vill. of HempsteadMatter of Gunther v. KellyLBMH Group, L.P. v. SaferSchwahl v. GrantWells Fargo Bank v. MeyersMancusi v. New York City Tr. Auth.Berkman v. Long Island Business SolutionsAmaya v. Long Is. Univ.In re Siani v. Farmingdale Coll. Found.Cambridge Integrated Serv. Gr. v. FaberFREBAR DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION v. POSNERKempisty v. 246 Spring Street, LLCBarry v. ManeenOXMAN v. 1100 PARK AVE. COOP. CORP.Matias v. Merck Sharp Dohme Corp.Troeller v. D.O.E. of the City Sch. Dist.Ryan v. HiatridesSingh v. SinghIn Matter of Farid v. EvansMATTER OF NASSAU CTY. CONSOL. MTBECabrini Care, Inc. v. King. Hgts. Care Ctr.Best Souvenirs v. 516 Fifth Ave. Partners LLCZapata v. Bovis Lend Lease LMB, Inc.Samuels v. Hunter Ambulette-Ambulance, Inc.In Matt. of Phys. Comm. for Resp. Med. v. HoganPeople v. TonyLBMH Group v. SaferBETHPAGE FED. CRED. UNION v. TAJ BLDG. PRODS. CO.Movado Group, Inc. v. Mozaffarian8 Catherine St., LLC v. NJC Constr., Inc.Dodds v. 1926 Third Ave. Realty Corp.JIN C. v. JULIANA LJ.E.K.A. v. Maggie Faith FlowersMURY v. ALLENPeople v. SantiagoIn Matter of Corozza v. Power AuthorityIn re Thakuri v. Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.MOUNT SINAI HOSP. v. DUST TR. INC.In Matter of New S. Ins. Co. v. SchafferMATTER OF LEWITIN v. MANHATTAN MINI STOR.Waring v. Metropolitan Suburban Bus Auth.Bernfeld v. KurilenkoSimon v. Time Warner Cable, Inc.Nigro v. N.Y. Racing Ass'n, Inc.Johnson v. Brooks8 Catherine St., LLC v. NJC Constr., Inc.Parson v. WeinsteinIn re App. Ealey v. N.Y.C. Hous. Auth.Thakuri v. Motor Veh. Acc. Indem. Corp.In Matter of Double J. Partners, LLC v. ForteRICHARDS v. GREAT ATLPeople v. WilliamsRubio v. RubioMURY v. ALLENIn re Appl. of Rosenthal v. KellyPlaza PH2001 LLC v. Plaza Residential Owner LPBernacchi v. County of SuffolkIn Matter of Rehab. of Frontier Insurance Co.STEIN v. THE ART STUDENTS LEAGUE OF N.Y.Develop Inc v. Empire CorpRH39 Realty, L.P. v. Parigi Intl., Inc.Emery Celli Brinkerhoff Abady, LLP v. RoseJohnson v. HermanDeutsche Bank Sec. Inc. v. Lexington Drake L.P.Arcia v. CannataWorld Alliance Fin. Corp. v. Guardian Funding Gp.INGUIL v. ROCHDALE VIL.DECATREL v. METRO LOFT MGT., LLCPeople v. Perez-LopezHSBC Mortg. Corp. (U.S.) v. CohenARUTA v. LO BUEIn re Gongora v. N.Y.C. D.O.E.Morales v. BoordBermingham v. PeterRodriguez v. 61 E. 72ND St. Corp.In Matter of Hartford Ins. Co. v. MulcahyCarter v. LevianMetcalf v. Progressive InsuranceDeFilippo v. Knolls of Melville Redev. Co.Valentl v. CaminsN.Y. Civil Liberties Union v. City of Saratoga SpringsGreen v. Tully Constr. Co. Inc.Antaki v. MateoThomas v. JohnMeadow Ridge Capital v. LeviDeutsche Bank Tr. Co. v. StathakisKABRO ASSOC. v. TOWN OF ISLIP ZBAPeople v. LenihanWeiss v. KaufmanShoecraft v. Town of N. SalemDemoya v. SinhaPeople v. DegoutPeople v. WilliamsINGUIL v. ROCHDALE VIL., INC.Garrett v.Stein v. Art Students LeaguePENNBUS REALTIES v. H EIGHTH AVEEUM v. STEPHENSGJF Constr. Corp. v. Creative Interiors PlusGaddy v. City of New YorkFrebar Dev. Corp. v. PosnerSingh v. City of New YorkSantana v. Long Island RailroadHopper v. LeograndeRichman v. Harleysville Worcester Ins. Co.Marquez v. KouyoudjianVillage of Pomona v. RamapoRichardson v. Neighborhood Hous. Assoc., LLCElmowitz v. DunneRoshodesh v. PlotchAlazraki v. GlynnShenendehowa Cent. Sch. Dist. Bd. of Educ. v. Civil Serv. Emps. Ass'n, Inc., Local 1000New Covenant Charter Sch. Educ. Faculty Ass'n v. Bd. of Trs. of the State Univ. of N.Y.Matter of HarrisPeople v. DegoutPeople v. GivensGOFF v. ROOSEVELT UNIONDEVELOP DON'T DESTROY v. EMPIRE STATE DEVBalsam v. FioriglioTeam Mktg. USA, Corp. v. Energy Brands, Inc.State of New York v. NelsonPlaza PH2001 LLC v. Plaza Residential Owner LPUlloa-Narvaez v. E L Realty of Suffolk Inc.Robinson v. Drury Enters., Inc.Balbuca-Morocho v. GPH Partners LLCAmer-A-Med Health Prods. v. Geico Ins.GORDON v. BARR BARR INC.GSD Prod. Servs., Inc. v. Vigilant Ins. Co.Greenberg Farrow Architecture, Inc. v. Renaissance Equity Holdings, LLCROBERTS v. HEALTH HOSPS. CORP.Berde v. North Shore-LongLLOYD v. SHENBrooklyn Fed. Saving v. 9096 Meserole St. RealtyCentury Ambulance Serv. v. AquinoIn Matter of Smith v. FischerColon v. Monroe Pediatric Assocs., P.C.IN RE STORMAN v. N.Y.C. DEPT. OF EDC.Kittelstad v. Losco Group Inc.Fedyszyn v. RubinIn Matter of Application of Ansah v. DouglasMolinari v. 167 Hous. Corp.BERDE v. NORTH SHOREMESSINA v. DeBLASIOrchard Mgmt. v. Insu. Co of Gr. N.Y.Storman v. N.Y. City Dept. of EducPeople v. LopezPERCIK v. USTUNDAGPeople v. LammyJohnson v. BrooksMeadow Ridge v. LeviForward v. FoschiPritzker v. Park S. LoftsINGUIL v. ROCHDALE VILFaith Ministries v. N.Y. State Div. of Hous.Washington Mut. Bank v. PhillipShein v. New York Presbyt. Hosp.Nyctl 1998-1 Trust v. CruzAponte v. City of New YorkAmerican Express Co. v. RivasClark v. Bishop Francis J. Mugavero Ctr.AZIZ v. MANLEYJENNINGS v. TEACHERS COLL.Thornton v. Village of FreeportCastro v. JK USA Group, Inc.R.D. Best Land Constr. v. Trust Under the WillSmith v. SmithGSO RE ONSHORE LLC v. SAPIR85 Unleashed, LLC v. Detroit Diesel-AllisonRivera v. City of New YorkDefilippo v. Knolls of MelvilleVaughn v. Med. Bd. of the Police Pension FundRyan v. Breezy Point CoopFrench v. SchjavoFAMA v. CITYSPIRE, INC.Peters v. Creative Lifestyles, Inc.RSB Bedford Assoc., LLC v. Rickys WilliamsburgJAO v. TRITEC BLDG. CO., INC.HUTTER v. JOEY TAXI INC.Knight v. Sterling Natl. BankYork v. MS Harrison LLCGerber v. WeissingerPersichilli v. Metro. Paper Recycling Inc.RH39 Realty, L.P. v. Parigi Int'l, Inc.Roberts v. New York City Hous. Auth.Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney, P.C. v. StiegThomas v. KirilukRSB Bedford Assocs. LLC v. Ricky's Williamsburg, Inc.Emery Celli Brinckerhoff v. RosePeople v. Harry Dorvilier And, Harry's Nurses Registry, Inc.CMIA PARTNERS EQUITY v. O'NEILLPeople v. Perez-LopezPlaza PH2001 v. Plaza ResidentialRoberts v. New York City Health & Hosp. Corp.Badalamenti v. Office of the Dist. Attorney Nassau Cnty.PENNBUS REALTIES, LLC v. H EIGHTH AVE. ASSOC.Matter of Mendelsohn v. KhodadadianIN RE LEWITIN v. MANHATTAN MINI STORAGEHampshire Cnty. Club v. Assessor of the Vill. of Mamaroneck & the Bd. of Assessment Review of MamaroneckTOWER INS. CO. OF N.Y. v. JAAP CONSTR., INC.Klein v. DooleyNinth Ave. Realty, LLC v. GuenanciaNASSAU COUNTY CONS. v. PIPELINE COMPANYMATTER OF NEW YORK CITY ASBESTOS LITIGATIONJohnson v. BrooksGeller v Rail Eur., Inc.GENTILE v. LIEBAHE REST. INC. v. 1374 THIRD AVE. INC.A D Intl. Corp. v. TerziNew Covenant Charter Sch. v. Board of TrusteesSmith v. N.Y. City DeptMATTER OF NASSAU COUNTY CONSOL. MTBELiddle v. LiddleHSBC Bank USA v. SchwartzBranch v. Metropolitan Suburban Bus Auth.Oxman v. 1100 Park Ave. Coop. Corp.Voom HD Holdings LLC v. Echostar Satellite L.L.C.HERMAN v. GAVEGeraci-Yee v. Freeport Union Free School Dist.MAIO v. VEROChirco v. City of Long BeachIn the Matter of The Application of Jaime Gongora v. N.Y. City Dep't of Educ.GSO RE ONSHORE LLC v. SAPIR9 Bleecker LLC v. Yippie Holdings, LLCMeadow Ridge Capital, LLC v. LeviJIN C. v. JULIANA L.LEWITIN v. STORIn re Shenendehowa Cent. Sch. v. Civ. Serv. Emp. Assn.Gall v. Colon-SylvanHarsch v. Island Boatyard, Inc.Orosz v. EppigHenry v. P. Deblasio, Inc.TUCHMAN v. DEAM PROPS., LLCRH39 RLTY., L.P. v. PARIGI INT'L, INC.In re Venus Group v. New York City Hous. Auth.DeMatteo Salvage Co. v. FarinoEncompass Ins. Co. v. AdelisLeignadier v. Credit Agricole, S.A.Rand v. Cornell Univ.Islamic Cultural Ctr. v. Village of Mont.Allen v. Waidmann Realty Corp.Castro v. JK USA GroupHAMPSHIRE COUNTRY CLUB v. ASSESSOR OF THE VILRosenthal v. KellyKelley v. South Shore HealthcareThree Hands Holdings, LLC v. LipmanGreenberg Farrow Archi. v. Renaissance Eq. Hldg.Harding v. Villages at Huntington Dev. Corp.Mount Sinai Hosp. v. Dust Transit Inc.MASQUE SOUND RECORDING v. LE POISSON ROUGEIn re Metropolitan Transportation AuthorityRICHARDS v. GREAT ATL. PAC. TEA CO. INC.Ramirez v. CruzPeople v. TorresIn Matter of Mcleod v. N. Y. City Hous. Auth.VOOM HD Holdings LLC v. Echostar Satellite L.L.C.RIFF v. STATEN ISLAND UNIVERSITY HOSPITAL