From Casetext: Smarter Legal Research

Davis v. Sheriff

Supreme Court of Nevada
Sep 22, 1977
93 Nev. 511 (Nev. 1977)

Opinion

No. 10113

September 22, 1977

Appeal from order denying pretrial petition for writ of habeas corpus, Eighth Judicial District Court, Clark County; Michael J. Wendell, J.

Morgan D. Harris, Public Defender, and Terrence M. Jackson, Deputy Public Defender, Clark County, for Appellant.

Robert List, Attorney General, Carson City; George E. Holt, District Attorney, and Jerry T. McGimsey, Deputy District Attorney, Clark County, for Respondent.


OPINION


After being ordered to stand trial for robbery (NRS 200.380), and attempted robbery (NRS 200.380; NRS 208.070), David Lewis Davis petitioned for habeas corpus, the thrust of which contended the charges must be dismissed because, although requested, the magistrate refused to conduct a closed preliminary hearing. Habeas was denied and Davis has appealed.

Davis argues that under our decision in Azbill v. Fisher, 84 Nev. 414, 442 P.2d 916 (1968), a closed hearing was mandatory, if requested, thus we are compelled to reverse. Indeed, Azbill did so hold; however, the statute under which Azbill was decided (NRS 171.204) was subsequently amended and now provides that a closed hearing is discretionary. See Stats. of Nev. 1969, ch. 364, p. 628. Here, Davis does not suggest that the magistrate's refusal to exclude the witnesses and conduct a closed hearing constituted an abuse of discretion; therefore, we affirm.

NRS 171.204 now provides:
"The magistrate may, upon the request of the defendant, exclude from the examination every person except his clerk, the prosecutor and his counsel, the attorney general, the district attorney of the county, the defendant and his counsel, the witness who is testifying, the officer having the defendant or a witness in his custody, and any other person whose presence is found by the magistrate to be necessary for the proper conduct of the examination." (Emphasis added.)


Summaries of

Davis v. Sheriff

Supreme Court of Nevada
Sep 22, 1977
93 Nev. 511 (Nev. 1977)
Case details for

Davis v. Sheriff

Case Details

Full title:DAVID LEWIS DAVIS, APPELLANT, v. SHERIFF, CLARK COUNTY, NEVADA, RESPONDENT

Court:Supreme Court of Nevada

Date published: Sep 22, 1977

Citations

93 Nev. 511 (Nev. 1977)
569 P.2d 402

Citing Cases

Dickinson Newspapers, Inc. v. Jorgensen

In states having a mandatory rule or statute requiring the exclusion of all unauthorized personnel, the…

Press-Enterprise Co. v. Superior Court

1983); Richmond Newspapers, Inc. v. Commonwealth, 222 Va. 574, 281 S.E.2d 915 (1981).See State v. McKenna, 78…